From City to State: Growing a Nonprofit Newsroom Across Maryland

How data-informed editorial strategy, a rebuilt mission, and a county-by-county expansion plan took The Baltimore Banner from a city-focused startup to Maryland's leading news source.

Audience Development · Editorial Strategy · Regional Expansion

The Context

The Baltimore Banner launched in June 2022 with a clear mandate: serve Baltimore. The organization was built on a $50 million investment over five years, with the goal of growing quickly, earning reader trust, and becoming financially sustainable before the runway ran out.

By 2023, the newsroom had hit its subscriber targets ahead of schedule and built a team of 75. But the data told a complicated story. Growth was happening, but it was uneven, driven by big breaking news moments and viral stories rather than consistent, sustained audience development. Sub starts had dipped. New visitor growth had stalled. Churn was high.

The uncomfortable truth: The Banner could not hit its long-term revenue targets by relying solely on Baltimore City readers. The market wasn't big enough. Sustainability required going regional.

Two women and one man standing inside a horse stable, engaging in conversation. The stable has a wooden roof and open sides, with horses visible in stalls along the wall. One woman is writing on a notepad, and the man appears to be explaining something. There are various supplies like buckets and tools around.

The Work

Rewriting the mission. The first and most important step was changing how the organization understood itself. The Banner's founding mission was to be "an indispensable resource that strengthens, unites, and inspires our Baltimore community." That framing made regional expansion feel like a departure from the mission. I worked to reframe the mission toward being "the most essential and compelling source of news in Maryland" — a self-sustaining enterprise that serves a broad and growing audience of Marylanders for many years to come. That shift changed how the entire newsroom thought about its work.

Data before decisions. Before moving a single reporter, I deployed an audience survey and commissioned a full analytics audit to understand what readers in the target counties actually wanted. The answer wasn't just "more news." It was specific: breaking news, crime, education, food, housing, and urban development — topics that intersect regional relevance with reader need.

Rebuilding the pitch system. I implemented a new editorial pitch framework across the regional team that required reporters to answer three questions before every story: Who is the audience? Why do they care? What is the potential impact? This simple change transformed how the team selected and framed stories — from coverage-for-coverage's-sake to coverage that served a specific reader need.

Structural realignment. I officially took over regional news in October 2024, onboarded a new regional editor, moved topical beats like transportation and environment to the regional team, and launched the inaugural Baltimore County headlines newsletter. I also deployed "roaming regional" reporters whose mandate was to find "relentlessly interesting" stories across the coverage area — not just attend meetings.

Brand built for scale. Alongside the editorial strategy, I oversaw the development of a regional brand system that gave each Maryland coverage area its own visual identity while keeping the Banner brand cohesive. Each region got its own color — named after Baltimore and Maryland landmarks — and its own logo treatment. It was a brand system built to scale.

Howard County as the test case.

Rather than expanding everywhere at once, I built a focused pilot in Howard County. This included a 12-week integrated marketing campaign, a coverage increase of 57% in county-specific articles, a new regional reporter hire, and the launch of a dedicated Howard County newsletter on September 19, 2024. The first edition got a 50% open rate.

The Howard County campaign results:

  • 13 million local impressions — 7x the normal baseline

  • 20,000 newsletter signups

  • Brand awareness grew to 48% in the county

  • Web traffic up 36% vs. flat for other regions

  • Email signups up 72% vs. 28% for other regions

  • Paid subscribers up 14% vs. 4% for other regions


Group of people at a conference, posing for a group photo behind a table with brochures and awards, in a room with beige walls and exit signs.

The Outcome

By the time I left The Baltimore Banner in September 2025, the organization had grown to 62,000 paid digital subscribers, well exceeding the original targets. Baltimore County traffic had reached an all-time high of 102,000 monthly users by October 2024, up from essentially nothing at launch. The Banner was recognized as Maryland's leading news source and one of the fastest-growing nonprofit newsrooms in the country.

The regional expansion wasn't just an editorial decision. It was the business decision that made sustainability possible.

WHAT THIS ILLUSTRATES

Regional expansion is one of the most complex strategic challenges a newsroom can take on. It requires alignment across editorial, marketing, product, and revenue teams. It requires a willingness to question the founding assumptions of the organization. And it requires the patience to test, learn, and iterate before scaling.

This is the kind of work I do, and the kind of challenge I'm built for.

Tell me what you're working on.
I'll tell you how I can help.